Book a Call

Home / Case Studies / The New Insurance Agency

Case study: Insurance

How a New Insurance Agency Under a Non-Compete Became the #1 Office on the East Coast

The owner had years of experience and a strict non-compete. Not one past client could be contacted. We built a Google profile, a website, search content, and a YouTube channel so new customers could find the agency on their own. The first policy came in 9 days.

9 daysto the first policy
#1 on the East Coastfor its carrier within 12 months
#5 nationallywithin 18 months
$40K a monthin residuals
What results did Evolution Media Group get for a new insurance agency?

Evolution Media Group built a Google Business Profile, website, SEO and AEO content, and a YouTube channel for a new insurance agency whose owner was under a strict non-compete. The agency wrote its first policy in 9 days, had steady leads within 60 days, became the #1 office on the East Coast for its carrier within 12 months and #5 nationally within 18 months, and reached $40,000 a month in residuals on about $2,500 a month of marketing.

The challenge

How do you build a book of business when you cannot call a single past client?

The owner had spent many years at one of the largest insurance offices in the area. When they opened their own agency, a strict non-compete meant they could not contact a single past client.

Years of relationships were off limits. The agency had to be found by people who had never heard of it, starting from zero, and it needed policies coming in fast to make the move work.

What they started with

  • Deep insurance experience and carrier relationships.
  • No book of business they were allowed to use.
  • No website, Google profile, reviews, or online presence for the new agency.

The agency had to win every customer from scratch, through search.

Snapshot

Industry
Insurance: home, auto, and life, then commercial
Starting point
New agency under a strict non-compete
Services
Google Business Profile, website build, SEO and AEO, YouTube
Investment
About $2,500 a month
Status
Still a client, growing in its territory

What we built

What did we build, and in what order?

  1. A Google Business Profile firstSet up and verified right away, with the right categories, every line of coverage, and service areas, so the agency could appear in local insurance searches from the first weeks.
  2. A website built for insurance shoppersA page for each line of coverage and each town, with direct answers to the questions people ask when they shop or switch, and schema so Google and AI tools understood the agency.
  3. SEO and AEO contentGuides and answers for the questions shoppers search, such as why rates go up, what coverage they need, and how to switch, each linked to the matching coverage page.
  4. A YouTube channelVideos answering the same questions in more depth, building trust with shoppers before they ever called.

Timeline

How fast did the results come?

  1. Day 9First policy written.
  2. Day 60Steady leads every week, from search and from the owner's networking.
  3. Month 12The #1 office on the East Coast for its carrier. Commercial lines added.
  4. Month 18#5 nationally for its carrier.
  5. Today$40,000 a month in residuals, two agents added, and a steady referral network.

The results

What changed for the agency?

Leads were steady within 60 days. The agency added two agents and kept them busy, then added commercial lines after about a year.

Within 12 months it was the #1 office on the East Coast for its carrier, and #5 nationally within 18 months, reaching $40,000 a month in residuals. The marketing cost about $2,500 a month and stayed flat as the book grew.

Today, people researching or shopping for insurance find the agency on their own. The book it built has turned into strong relationships with clients, real estate agents, and mortgage lenders, and those relationships now send referrals too.

"This worked a lot better and a lot faster than I expected. I was afraid we would get off to a slow start and it would take time to build a book of business, but we were building from practically day one."
The owner, in conversation with Harrison Smith

Why it worked

Why did it work without a single past client?

Search does not need a network

Shoppers comparing insurance search on their own. A strong Google profile and website put the agency in front of them without any existing relationships.

Google profile first

Starting with the profile got the agency into local searches within days, while the website and content were still being built.

Answers build trust

Content and videos answered the questions shoppers ask when rates change, so the agency was the expert they already trusted when they called.

A fixed cost that scaled

About $2,500 a month built an owned system. The cost stayed flat while the book of business, and then the referrals, kept growing.

What is next

What is next for this client?

They are still a client and continue to grow within their existing territory. Search keeps bringing in new shoppers, and the relationships built from the book of business keep bringing in referrals from clients, real estate agents, and mortgage lenders.

Use the same system

The services behind this result, with published pricing. See also google business profile management, youtube management.

Not ready for a call?

See how your business compares to this system

The Marketing Growth Scorecard grades the same pieces we built here: your website, Google profile, content, and follow-up. Five minutes, and your report shows your top fixes.

Questions

Questions about this case study

How fast did the new insurance agency get results?

The first policy was written in 9 days and leads were steady within 60 days. The agency became the #1 office on the East Coast for its carrier within 12 months and #5 nationally within 18 months.

How can an insurance agent grow under a non-compete?

By being found by new customers instead of contacting old ones. A Google Business Profile, a website with coverage and town pages, and content that answers shopper questions bring in people who have never heard of the agency. Check the terms of your own agreement with an attorney.

How much did the insurance agency spend on marketing?

About $2,500 a month. The cost stayed flat as the book of business grew to $40,000 a month in residuals.

What services did the insurance agency use?

Google Business Profile management, a new website, SEO and AEO content, and YouTube. See SEO for insurance agents.

Want results like this in your market?

Book a free 30-minute call. We will look at your website, Google profile, and competitors, and show you where the opening is.